India

Police Violence in India: The State’s Culture of Impunity

By admin
7 min read


“So now you will do duty, not trade (sauda)?”

In Gajab Raat, the series that recently dropped on Netflix, this is the question that Nirvit, an investigating officer played by Manoj Bajpayee, is asked by his senior officer when he declares that he will pursue his duty, that is, catch the criminal. The question reveals that this is an unusual decision for Nirvit to take; for decades he has been a policeman on the take. And even now, he began the case fully prepared to kill Arya, a young journalist lying in hospital after being grievously attacked, in return for a hefty bribe. What changed his mind was seeing her parents’ grief. Even so, his conversion is neither heroic nor complete. Short of police personnel to protect Arya, he recruits the men he has just arrested a scene ago, men linked with sex work, from whom he routinely takes money in return for their release. The same men become his reinforcements. Sauda or trade has not disappeared; it has only been renamed duty, and instead of giving money they give him muscle.

The film may be fiction, but its question is not: what does the Indian state trade in? The answer increasingly is violence, and impunity is the currency. Police beat, torture, rape, and kill, and the burden falls disproportionately on the poor, Dalits, Adivasis, and Muslims. The Status of Policing in India Report (SPIR) 2025 names them as the most frequent targets of violence. Figures tabled in the Lok Sabha put deaths in police custody between 2025 and 2026 (until March) at 170.

In October, this violence was seen blatantly on the streets. UN experts said the police used excessive force, including lathi charges, against unarmed and peaceful student protesters in Delhi and elsewhere over three months, and called for an impartial investigation. India has repeatedly dismissed such criticism as interference in its internal affairs. Whatever the facts of any one day, the legal test is clear. Police may disperse an unlawful assembly, but the force must be proportionate. An order to clear a road is lawful. An order to strike a student already on the ground is not.

Yet can we expect a constable to refuse an unlawful order when the state controls what happens if they do? A 2019 survey found that personnel worked 14 hours a day on average, one in three frequently experienced political pressure in investigations, and 60 per cent feared a transfer if they did not comply with such pressure. While this will not excuse the violence, it complicates the question of who is acting and at whose behest.

The violence is not new

The police violence that played out on city streets against ordinary citizens might have been new and shocking to many Indians, but not to those who have long lived with it. For migrant and informal workers, sex workers, transgender persons, and Dalit, Adivasi and Muslim communities, harassment, beatings, sexual violence, and custodial deaths have long been routine. In Kashmir and the northeastern States, the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958 (AFSPA) has for decades allowed soldiers to use lethal force on suspicion alone. It is the same logic that has now appeared in the “encounter” killings, in the punitive bulldozing of homes, in shooting criminals in the leg with the intention to lame, and in lathi charges against protesters. Many people in border regions have long stopped being able to treat the police as an institution they can call upon to help or protect; instead, they see it as the power that will determine their survival.

A state that treats violence as normal teaches everyone else that it is. In 2015, Mohammad Akhlaq was beaten to death by a mob in Dadri on a rumour about beef. In 2017, Pehlu Khan, a dairy farmer, was lynched in Alwar while transporting cattle with valid documents. In 2016, Dalit men were stripped and flogged in Una for skinning a dead cow. Victims are chosen by identity and the crowd acted with the assurance that comes from expecting that nothing will happen to them. Often, nothing does. All six men accused in Pehlu Khan’s killing were acquitted in 2019.

The same impunity shapes sexual violence. In Hathras in 2020, a Dalit teenager died after being raped by a gang of men. Her family said that the police cremated her body past midnight without their consent; police said it was done as per the family’s wishes. The Allahabad High Court asked whether the body would have been cremated so quickly and secretly had she come from a well-to-do family. In Manipur in 2023, the world saw two women paraded naked by a mob only because a video surfaced months later. Wherever the state shows that some lives and some bodies do not matter, others in society take the cue.

The relatives of the stampede victims waiting to collect the body outside the mortuary at Hathras in Uttar Pradesh on July 3, 2024.

The relatives of the stampede victims waiting to collect the body outside the mortuary at Hathras in Uttar Pradesh on July 3, 2024.
| Photo Credit:
MOORTHY R.V

Nor is violence only a matter of orders. It depends also on belief. In the SPIR 2019, in a survey of 12,000 police personnel, responding to a question whether Muslims are “naturally prone to crime”, 14 per cent said “very much” while 36 per cent said “somewhat”. Such attitudes do not remain private opinions when the men and women holding such opinions can register a complaint, investigate an offence, or make an arrest. The prejudice of the street and the prejudice of the police station then feed each other.

When violence does surface for scrutiny, answers come slowly, if at all. In 2018, 31 years after the Hashimpura killings of 1987, the Delhi High Court convicted 16 former Provincial Armed Constabulary men for shooting dead 42 to 46 Muslim men who were rounded up in Meerut and taken to an irrigation canal before being shot and dumped in the water. The verdict called it a targeted killing of unarmed people by state forces. But the gap of 31 years before the verdict was not just justice delayed; it was a message about the kinds of cases that the state will wait out.

Gajab Raat unfolds over a single night, and for many ordinary Indians, so does everything that matters. In 2022, more than half the custodial deaths involved people held in the first 24 hours after arrest, before any court had remanded them. In those hours, the only witnesses are other police personnel. On the morning of November 14, in Madurai district of Tamil Nadu, a truck driver taken into police custody the previous day and kept for overnight questioning was found dead.

Nothing in those hours of custody guarantees that the police personnel will favour duty over sauda. In the fictional series, a family’s grief moved Nirvit. In March 2026, six years after the incident, a woman constable’s courage helped convict nine police personnel in Tamil Nadu for the custodial murder of a father and son. Conscience does and must play a role, but it makes a precarious foundation for justice.

A system that waits for the right “conscientious” person to be on shift is not a system but a wager with human lives. And a state that shrugs off violence or commits violence openly or seems to condone it as “natural justice” sets the terms on which every beat constable and every ordinary person on the street thereafter behaves, thus perpetuating the cycle of violence.

Pankhuri Agarwal is a lecturer and Leverhulme Fellow at King’s College London. She is also the author of Fictions of Freedom, Cambridge University Press, 2026, open access.

Also Read | India Persecution Tracker: 2026 deadliest year for Muslims

Also Read | The police should be made an autonomous institution: Meeran Chadha Borwankar



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Saved Articles