India

Kamaraj: When Gandhian Ideals Met the Welfare State

By admin
8 min read


Around October 2, the noticeboard outside Kamarajar Memorial School in Mumbai’s Dharavi takes on a particular cast. Mahatma Gandhi and Lal Bahadur Shastri are there, as expected, but so is Kamarajar, his portrait drawn larger than either. Perunthalaivar K. Kamaraj died in Madras on October 2, 1975. Crowds filed past his body at Rajaji Hall before he was buried at Gandhi Mandapam in Guindy, Chennai.

A coincidence of dates aside, Gandhi and Kamaraj had little interaction. But what little there was, during Gandhi’s last visit to the south in 1946, proved consequential. Through Kamaraj’s 20 years in the freedom struggle, Gandhi had been nothing less than a god to him; meeting him was a dharisanam (sight of a deity). Yet the deity barely registered the devotee. He named Kamaraj only twice in writing, in Harijan dispatches of February 1946, and each time poured fuel on a fire already burning.

Chakravarti Rajagopalachari, popularly known as Rajaji, who had broken with the Congress over Quit India in 1942 while Kamaraj and the cadres went to jail, was now seeking a way back, and the Tamil Nadu Congress Committee (TNCC) wanted none of it.

Also Read | The hooch and the Mahatma

In the first of the two dispatches, Gandhi lamented a “clique” working against Rajaji within the TNCC. The newspaper Dinamani rendered the word as kumbal, a lowly gang, and it was read as a direct hit at TNCC president Kamaraj, cast as the gang leader. Deeply anguished, Kamaraj asked publicly why Gandhi had said nothing to him when he had been within calling distance throughout the tour. Then he resigned from the party’s parliamentary board on the eve of the provincial elections.

In the second, having taken note of the uproar, Gandhi said he would not involve himself in local politics, but refused to withdraw the word. While admitting he had not spoken much with Kamaraj on the tour, he maintained that cliques existed in every organisation, TNCC included. He then questioned whether Kamaraj was his follower at all. A true follower would have written to him first, and held firm in a difficult post instead of resigning.

The episode was fodder for the Congress’ opponents. In the weekly Dravida Nadu, C.N. Annadurai, then of the Dravidar Kazhagam, wrote a polemic that made a martyr of Kamaraj: a brave non-Brahmin whose self-respect had been destroyed by his own Mahatma. Harassed by Achariyar (Rajaji), ignored by Gandhiyar, and tormented by the cruel kumbal comment, Kamaraj had wept publicly, and that sight wounded the Tamil heart, he declared.

Learning through protests

Even before their direct encounter in 1946, Kamaraj had been in campaigns Gandhi judged from afar, and not always kindly.

Kamaraj’s first taste of agitation, his biographers say, came at Vaikom in 1924, where the Congress volunteers were fighting for oppressed castes’ right to walk the roads around a Travancore temple. In 1925, Gandhi settled for a compromise. Three of the four roads were opened, while the larger fight for temple entry was suspended.

Two years on came a different protest. Young men took to the streets in Madurai with swords, daring the government to arrest them under the Arms Act. Kamaraj was among those handing the swords out. When the volunteers told Gandhi in Madras that it had been a success, he laughed. Instruments of violence made no one a satyagrahi, let alone a successful one.

The statue of Colonel James Neill in Egmore Museum, Chennai.

The statue of Colonel James Neill in Egmore Museum, Chennai.
| Photo Credit:
S.R. Raghunathan

The laughter was a prelude. The volunteers, Kamaraj among them, had come to Gandhi to strategise for a brewing campaign: the removal of the statue of Colonel James Neill on Mount Road, the officer responsible for brutal reprisals in Allahabad and Cawnpore during the 1857 uprising. Though Gandhi agreed that the demand was just, he doubted whether the cadres had yet acquired the discipline of satyagraha. He advised them to suspend the campaign for three months and restart only when they were ready to conduct it non-violently, as a last resort, bearing no hatred for the British.

The volunteers, fearing a pause would demoralise them, pressed on, and Gandhi let them. Kamaraj, too, chose momentum over self-examination. In the weeks that followed, he took to the platforms with fiery speeches, but the agitation eventually fizzled out.

His first prison term followed in 1930, after the Vedaranyam salt march led by Rajaji. Seven years later, he entered the Madras Assembly unopposed as Rajaji became Premier. Rajaji’s ministry finished what the Neill satyagrahis had started, moving the statue into the Madras Museum, and took a significant legal step towards temple entry for Dalits. Gandhi’s trust in his southern commander only deepened.

From protest to policy

The commander walked out in 1942, opposed to Quit India and to the party’s refusal to concede the principle of Pakistan for a settlement with the Muslim League. The cadres who went to jail turned instead to Kamaraj, TNCC president since 1940. Even after the clique episode, his word decided who became Premier of Madras in 1947 and again in 1949.

Rajaji returned to lead Madras in 1952. The following year, his government halved the school day and asked children to spend the other half learning their parents’ occupations. On paper, it drew on Gandhi’s 1937 Wardha Scheme, which put a craft such as spinning at the centre of schooling.

But for Gandhi, the school chose the craft; for Rajaji, birth did. Periyar E.V. Ramasamy called it kula kalvi thittam, caste-based education, and Congress legislators rose against the scheme in open revolt. In 1954, Rajaji resigned, and Kamaraj became Chief Minister.

One of Kamaraj’s earliest actions was to scrap kula kalvi. What followed was a sustained expansion of primary schooling. Closed schools reopened, thousands of new ones were built, and teachers were given pensions and insurance. Most consequentially, the government began serving children a free midday meal. Gandhi’s scheme had imagined schools paid for by the children’s own craft. Kamaraj’s fed them instead, paid for by the state. It was a departure from Gandhi’s method, but faithful to what he meant to achieve: every child, however poor, in school.

Kamaraj’s attention to primary schools did not come at the expense of higher education. In admissions to medical and engineering colleges, the interview was where an applicant’s social background could earn extra marks, and Rajaji’s government had cut its weight. Kamaraj restored it, reopening the door for first-generation students and those from marginalised castes.

But his instinct was always for the village. Funds from the Five-Year Plans were put to unusually good use in the Madras countryside, with irrigation and rural electrification reaching regions that had known neither. The self-reliant village Gandhi had long preached, one that could feed and employ itself, was, for the first time, within sight.

The record cemented Periyar’s trust in Kamaraj, whom he called the Pachai Tamizhan, the pure Tamilian, and backed throughout his tenure despite his own contempt for the Congress. So when Periyar learned that Kamaraj meant to give up office, he wired him in alarm, calling the step suicidal. Kamaraj went ahead, in the Gandhian spirit of renunciation, to strengthen the party at the grassroots. He resigned in 1963, on October 2.

A true follower

Regionally, it was indeed suicidal. The anti-Hindi agitation of 1965, the rice shortage that followed, and a mismanaged state government cost the Congress Madras in 1967. It has not led the state government since. Kamaraj, by then Congress president, was steering the party through turbulent years at the Centre. Under him, democratic socialism became its formal creed. For all the gods in the land, he liked to say, none had come to rescue the poor. Only the state could.

Rajaji disagreed. He had left the Congress by then to found the Swatantra Party, which spoke of freedom from the state in terms that Gandhi might have recognised. But it drew princes, landlords, and big business to its side—those least likely to serve Gandhi’s ends.

Rajaji might have been the one with Gandhi’s favour, but Kamaraj’s time in power was more representative of Gandhi’s goals.

Rajaji might have been the one with Gandhi’s favour, but Kamaraj’s time in power was more representative of Gandhi’s goals.
| Photo Credit:
The Hindu Archives

More ridiculous still were the sadhus who borrowed his language of satyagraha. In 1966, they marched on Parliament to demand a national ban on cow slaughter, a measure Gandhi had explicitly opposed. The protest turned violent, and the mob set fire to the house of Kamaraj, who had resisted the ban.

Gandhi can be interpreted in many ways, and few could meet his tests of purity; by his own admission, not even he always did. Neither Rajaji nor Kamaraj did. In their long political lives, we can always pick moments, not least electoral ones, to draw convenient ideological conclusions. Who would have imagined the two rivals, in 1971, allied against Indira Gandhi’s radical, if populist, welfarism?

Also Read | The past we choose to remember

What matters more is what each did once power was in his hands. Gandhi left a talisman for that: to ask whether our actions will be of any use to the weakest person we know, whether we can restore them to control over their own destiny. Rajaji may have been the keeper of Gandhi’s conscience. But by the measure of that talisman, Kamaraj was its most faithful executor.

Surya Bulusu is a researcher and software engineer at Avanti Fellows, a non-profit building open-source technology for public schools. He writes on books, cities, and history.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Saved Articles