India

How Sonia Gandhi’s memoir traces the Congress-RSS confrontation

By admin
8 min read


Sonia Gandhi, in the prologue to Belonging: A Journey of Love, writes that “politics is the background, a kind of framework” for her memoir. The framework in which she has chosen to tell her story, however, is the clash between the ideologies of the Congress and the RSS. The Congress, in Sonia’s telling, seeks to preserve the secular, inclusive character of the Indian Republic against the RSS’ quest to transform it into a Hindu rashtra.

This clash of ideologies has led the Hindu right-wing ecosystem to relentlessly vilify the Nehru-Gandhi family. Sonia had her first taste of their venom after her prematurely born first child died. A right-wing opposition paper wrote, “Indira Gandhi failed in her attempt to become the grandmother of a bastard child.” The remark seared her heart, she writes, despite her husband Rajiv Gandhi explaining that “such calumny about his family was a common daily occurrence”.

That “common daily occurrence” persists to this day. The internet still buzzes with scurrilous fabrications about Jawaharlal Nehru, Indira Gandhi, and even Motilal Nehru and his ancestors. Sonia quips, “The RSS propaganda machine has worked overtime for decades and seems never to take a day off.”

She finds the RSS lurking behind every momentous event in the Congress. In 1969, Indira supported V.V. Giri against Neelam Sanjiva Reddy, the candidate of the old guard in the Congress—the Syndicate—in the presidential election. Seeking to stall Indira’s radical economic policies, the Syndicate took the support of the Swatantra Party, formed, according to Sonia, by leaders opposed to the Congress’ socialist politics, and the Jan Sangh, the BJP’s earlier incarnation, in the presidential contest.

Giri’s triumph split the Congress. Sonia gives an ideological frame to the battle for power between Indira and the Syndicate. She writes, “In Mrs. Gandhi’s view, seeking the support of such parties was a betrayal of the Congress’s stand against rightwing and communal forces.” From Sonia’s perspective, these forces have since striven to undermine the Congress.

Their role was evident to her during the 1973-1974 Nav Nirman Andolan in Gujarat. Triggered by high mess bills and poor quality of food in student hostels, the agitation snowballed into a powerful anti-corruption onslaught against the Congress government. Almost a hundred people died in the rioting, which was, Sonia writes, “spurred on by the RSS, through the Jan Sangh’s student front, the ABVP (Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad).”

The JP movement

Around the same time, the ABVP-led student protest rocked Bihar, where a new impetus came with Jayaprakash Narayan, or JP, joining it. The State Assembly was picketed, MLAs were gheraoed, and private and public buildings torched.

Sonia doesn’t fault the Congress for poor governance. Rather, in this context, she recalls Indira’s “prescient” observation, made to Nehru 30 years earlier, that the growth of the RSS resembled that of the Brownshirts in Germany, and that it could grow out of control unless checked quickly. For Sonia, Bihar and Gujarat starkly bore out Indira’s prediction.

Then came the political typhoon on June 12, 1975. On that day, the Allahabad High Court declared Indira’s election invalid and debarred her from contesting elections for six years. Sonia says her mother-in-law had expected the High Court to deliver such a judgment.

Sonia, then, drops a bombshell—Indira’s expectations were based on the Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister having intercepted, even before the High Court’s judgment, JP’s message to Sanjiva Reddy, saying, “She will be disqualified for six years. This is the time for us to attack.” Sonia doesn’t cite the source of the intercepted message.

Yet, if this is true, Indira can’t be blamed for believing that a conspiracy was afoot against her. And so, when Rajiv counselled his mother to resign in the wake of the High Court judgment, Indira lamented that JP had fallen prey to the designs of the RSS, which was “merely using him to achieve their ends”. On another occasion, Indira told Rajiv, “If I resign, the party will split and scatter, and the RSS will have its way.”

This fear seems to have determined Indira’s choice. Sonia quotes her as saying, “I know these people. I know their history. I know what their aim is; they want to finish the party.” Indira’s perception was shared by her younger son, Sanjay Gandhi, who, in an argument with Rajiv, retorted, “How can you say that [that is, to resign]? They’re bent on destroying Ma’s position and the party.”

The Gandhis, in Sonia’s retelling, seemed more apprehensive of the RSS’ machinations than JP’s popularity. The Emergency was imposed a day after the Supreme Court, hearing an appeal against the High Court judgment, disallowed Indira from voting in the Lok Sabha on June 24.

Enter RSS

The RSS next enters Belonging after Rajiv was elected to the Lok Sabha in 1981, following Sanjay’s death in a plane crash. His widow, Maneka Gandhi, was miffed that a political position had been denied to her by Indira, who was back in the Prime Minister’s saddle. Her reasons for doing so, Sonia explains, were that Maneka was “still too young and immature” and needed to nurture her three-month old child, Varun.

Maneka was prepared to take the battle to Indira. She rebuffed Indira’s suggestion of holding a small get-together to celebrate Varun’s first birthday. Yet Maneka held the birthday party at the residence of Vasundhara Raje, the daughter of Vijaya Raje Scindia, a staunch RSS supporter who contested against Indira in the 1980 Lok Sabha election.

The fight in the Gandhi family took a vicious turn with Maneka selling the Surya magazine, floated during the Emergency by her and backed by Sanjay, to a “close associate” of Vijaya Raje. Sonia doesn’t disclose the buyer’s identity. There were in fact two buyers, Ved Mehta wrote in a piece published in The New Yorker in May 1983—Dr J.K. Jain and Sardar S.C. Angre, both close to the RSS, with the latter described as Vijaya Raje’s private secretary and confidant.

The magazine’s sale to them, according to Sonia, was “tantamount to insulting not only Indira but the memory of her son, of her father, of all those who had fought against the RSS’s communal ideology…” After an acrimonious exchange with Indira before a gaggle of journalists, Maneka exited the prime ministerial residence, an incident dealt with fleetingly in Belonging—but extraordinarily detailed in Mehta’s piece.

Sonia writes that the RSS, a Mumbai industrialist and a newspaper baron together egged on President Zail Singh to dismiss Rajiv as Prime Minister. Singh was contemplating this grossly unconstitutional step, according to Sonia, because he wanted a second term as President. This is borne out by, yet again, Mehta’s 1988 report in The New Yorker.

It was during Rajiv’s prime ministerial tenure that the RSS launched the Ram Janmabhoomi movement, which Sonia labels as an attempt to “seek an emotive issue that would advance their agenda”. Simultaneously, the old strategy of discrediting the Congress leadership continued, with “false stories disseminated by the RSS and its camp followers…and rumours spread through hawkers and tobacco shops in local markets or at railway stations….”

Sonia glosses over V.P. Singh’s decision to grant 27 per cent reservation to the Other Backward Classes, a move that wrecked the Congress as much as the temple issue did. She presumably did so because Singh’s move wasn’t inspired by the RSS. Her narrative choice shows that Belonging has been crafted as a sophisticated diatribe against the RSS dressed as a “personal memoir”. She juxtaposes the cosmopolitanism of the Gandhis, as much informed by the Indian-Hindu tradition as by modernity, with the RSS’ parochial and xenophobic outlook—and subtly entices readers to choose between the two.

Rahul Gandhi now heads the family’s battle against the RSS, which, to Sonia’s sorrow, disparages him as viciously as it did his father, grandmother, and great-grandfather. “It breaks my heart to witness the level of aggression Rahul had to endure… He was given derogatory epithets; social media trolls were unleashed to mock him…,” says Sonia, who finds no fault in her children, just as she didn’t in her husband.

Even the most worthless leader doesn’t deserve the vilification to which Rahul has been subjected. That it hasn’t broken him can be explained by an anecdote that Sonia narrates. Months after Indira was voted out in 1977, the family decided to celebrate Rahul’s seventh birthday. Of all the friends invited to the celebration, only one turned up, presumably because the parents of the others were afraid of incurring the wrath of the Janata Party government.

“We could see how hurt and downcast Rahul was… We cut the cake, but without much cheer,” Sonia notes. Having learnt in childhood that kindness isn’t guaranteed even from friends, Rahul perhaps doesn’t, as an adult, expect it from the family’s unrelenting foe—the RSS.

Ajaz Ashraf is a senior journalist from Delhi and the author of Bhima Koregaon: Challenging Caste.

Also Read | Sonia Gandhi and the unending agony of belonging

Also Read | Synthetic misogyny



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Saved Articles