India

Tamil Nadu’s dissolution of Kurian Committee raises questions on federalism

By admin
7 min read


Praveen Chakravarty’s “A committee ain’t the cause”, published on November 18 in The New Indian Express, defends the Tamil Nadu government’s decision to dissolve the High-Level Committee on Union-State Relations chaired by Justice Kurian Joseph. His case is that a committee is a tool, federalism is the cause, and the cause will outlive the tool. It helps to know who is making this defence. Chakravarty is a Congress MP who entered the Rajya Sabha in June with backing from the Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK). In other words, he is defending the government that gave him a seat in Parliament. My own stake is plain: I was a Research Officer on the Kurian Committee until the evening it was dissolved.

The Kurian Committee was asked to examine the Constitution provision by provision, along with the laws and policies that govern Union-State relations, and to recommend measures to secure “utmost autonomy” for the States without prejudice to the unity of the country. Part I was submitted on schedule on February 16, with 10 chapters and roughly 100 recommendations. Part II was about 60 per cent complete, and it covered emergency provisions, Central agencies, and the legislative, administrative, and fiscal relations between the Union and the States. Chakravarty has argued that since Part I is in the public domain, little is lost, but that is not true. In fact, the depth of Part I showed what the committee could have done had it been allowed to continue.

Chakravarty is right that a body created by executive order can be dissolved by one, but it was not the legality of the dissolution that was in question, but its prudence. Equally, the precedents he cites, the DMK replacing the members of the Child Rights Commission in 2022, and Kerala closing the Loka Kerala Sabha, do not fit the argument. In the former case, the standing commission can keep working with new members; and the latter is about an expatriate forum, not a research committee.

Also, the manner of shutting down the commission was not honest. After the TVK took office in May, Minister Vanni Arasu spoke in the Assembly on May 13 against closing the committee. The committee was asked to continue but with one condition: the Secretary and Research Officer, a former Registrar of the University of Madras and a respected economist who had served on the State Planning Commission, was asked to leave because the government doubted his political leanings. Despite his leaving, the committee was dissolved just six months later. The committee’s staff were removed one by one: the office assistants and accountant in August, and the translator in October. When the dissolution order came on the evening of November 6, ahead of a long weekend, it did not seem to be issued by a government that was sure of its reasons.

Chakravarty’s sharpest charge is that the political associations of the members raised doubts about their neutrality. The member whose family ties he alludes to, Prof. M. Naganathan, resigned on May 4, six months before the dissolution. The remaining member, K. Ashok Vardhan Shetty, is a retired IAS officer who has served governments of every stripe. Working closely with any Chief Minister is what senior civil servants do. The committee chair was a former Supreme Court judge; was his neutrality also suspect?

A fairer test of the committee might be to see how its work was received. Justice J. Chelameswar called Part I timely and scholarly. Advocates Gautam Bhatia, Faizan Mustafa, and Sanjay Hegde commended it. Two serving BJP Union Ministers wrote in praise of it. As did sitting judges of four High Courts, a former Election Commissioner, and a former Union Finance Secretary. Chakravarty’s own colleagues in the Congress offered warm praise: Siddaramaiah said Karnataka shared the concerns expressed in Part I, while Mani Shankar Aiyar urged that its work be followed up, regardless of the outcome of the Tamil Nadu election. That the DMK cited the report in its campaign is not enough to counter this.

The government’s main defence, which Chakravarty unquestioningly accepts, is that the State Law Commission duplicates the committee’s work. That, however, is not the case. The Law Commission, which has been reconstituted every three years since 1994 on inherited terms, carries Centre-State relations as one line in a general brief on law reform.

The dissolution order also calls the committee non-statutory, but so is the Law Commission.

The dissolution order and Chakravarty’s article seem to indicate that it is only a question of files being transferred. The rigour, however, might not be that easy to replicate. The committee strove to ensure that no recommendation in Part I contradicted another; equally, the committee was careful that nothing in Part II would collide with Part I. Keeping 100-odd proposals across 25 chapters consistent with each other is a Herculean task, and only a team that carries the whole design in its head can do it.

Moreover, handing the work of a former Supreme Court judge to another body headed by a former High Court judge appears to this writer to be a needless slight to Justice Kurian Joseph.

There are two situations in which a committee’s work is rightly handed over to someone else. One is when the committee has not worked and has missed its deadlines. The other is when its output is poor and has been badly received. Neither applies here. Indeed, it was the exact opposite. The report was delivered on time, and it was praised across party lines. One wonders if perhaps that was the problem. The committee would ordinarily have delivered Part II by May 2027. Now, handing over the work to a body with no team, no timetable, and no deadline is a reliable way to ensure the report never lands.

Minister with no jurisdiction

There is also the question that Chakravarty avoids: Who wanted this? The committee came under the Public (Law and Order-F) Department, which reports to the Chief Minister. Yet, when the decision to dissolve it drew criticism, it was Law Minister C.T.R. Nirmal Kumar who responded, even though his department had nothing to do with the committee. The government’s own order names the Secretary, Public Department, as our single point of contact; the Law Department appears only in the copy list. Nirmal Kumar’s name surfaced first in September, in media reports of pressure on Justice Kurian Joseph to resign.

In his six months in office, the Chief Minister did not meet Justice Joseph even once; neither has he commented on the issue since. Nirmal Kumar came to the TVK through the AIADMK, after years in the BJP. Meanwhile, a prominent political voice that welcomed the dissolution was the BJP Tamil Nadu’s chief spokesperson, Narayanan Thirupathy. It is pertinent to ask why a Minister with no jurisdiction was so invested in ending a committee on federal distribution of powers, and why is the Chief Minister silent?

A question for the Congress

Even more puzzling is Chakravarty’s defence. His party fights the BJP on the subject of federalism; his party leader resolutely reminds Parliament that India is a Union of States. Yet here is a Congress MP lending his pen to a decision driven by a former BJP man and cheered on by the BJP. Does the party high command have anything to say about its member’s stance? One may fairly ask whether federalism for the Congress is a matter of principle or convenience.

Chakravarty says federalism belongs to no party. I agree. That is exactly why the committee should have been allowed to finish its task. Its recommendations would serve every State, including one headed by a TVK government. Today, nobody asks which party appointed the Rajamannar Committee. They read its report.

A committee is not the cause. But a cause with nobody doing the work is only a slogan.

R. Vanchinathan was a Research Officer with the High-Level Committee on Union-State Relations (Justice Kurian Joseph Committee), Government of Tamil Nadu.

Also Read | Dalit women’s freedom begins with land, power and a voice

Also Read | Kamaraj, the disciple Gandhi overlooked



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Saved Articles